Hope you don't mind me stepping in; I also find it's all a little sketchy. She initially claimed that the incident happened when while she was on the phone to him, that they started to fight and he threw the phone through a glass window causing his injury - she was allegedly in London filming the Danish Girl.justintime wrote:Also, I thought AH was not even in Australia when JD hurt his finger - was that whole original story another AH elaborate lie? Should be easy to prove. What hell Johnny has been through!
At some point, Suzanne Witkin potsed on her facebook page that the injury was caused by Amber herself. This post was removed, but not before a number of people saw it.
Later AH's story changed and she provided significant details of how the injury occurred, including how he then went on to daub the ''easy Amber'' message on a mirror in paint using his finger. Unless there was someone else who witnessed the incident and took photos of the mirror (and his finger), passing both on to her, she wouldn't have known what he'd done since by her account the latter happened after he'd thrown the phone.
I don't know if we'll ever learn the absolute truth, but I would not be surprised to learn that it was Johnny's idea to say she wasn't present - that seems to be his MO. This (Johnny's) account seems to be the most logical and fits in with SW's post (may be she was asked to remove it for this reason?) and AH's own stupid account putting her in the first person.
I hate to think of the full extent of Johnny's suffering at the hands of this vile individual.